The Silent Sex: Gender, Deliberation, and Institutions
Christopher F. Karpowitz and Tali Mendelberg
Abstract
Do women participate in and influence meetings equally with men? Does gender shape how a meeting is run and whose voices are heard? This book shows how the gender composition and rules of a deliberative body dramatically affect who speaks, how the group interacts, the kinds of issues the group takes up, whose voices prevail, and what the group ultimately decides. It argues that efforts to improve the representation of women will fall short unless they address institutional rules that impede women's voices. Using experimental research supplemented with analysis of school boards, the book demons ... More
Do women participate in and influence meetings equally with men? Does gender shape how a meeting is run and whose voices are heard? This book shows how the gender composition and rules of a deliberative body dramatically affect who speaks, how the group interacts, the kinds of issues the group takes up, whose voices prevail, and what the group ultimately decides. It argues that efforts to improve the representation of women will fall short unless they address institutional rules that impede women's voices. Using experimental research supplemented with analysis of school boards, the book demonstrate how the effects of rules depend on women's numbers, so that small numbers are not fatal with a consensus process, but consensus is not always beneficial when there are large numbers of women. Men and women enter deliberative settings facing different expectations about their influence and authority. The book reveals how the wrong institutional rules can exacerbate women's deficit of authority while the right rules can close it, and, in the process, establish more cooperative norms of group behavior and more generous policies for the disadvantaged. Rules and numbers have far-reaching implications for the representation of women and their interests. This book provides important new findings on ways to bring women's voices into the conversation on matters of common concern.
Keywords:
gender,
meetings,
gender composition,
group interaction,
consensus process,
influence,
authority,
group behaviour,
representation,
women
Bibliographic Information
Print publication date: 2014 |
Print ISBN-13: 9780691159751 |
Published to Princeton Scholarship Online: October 2017 |
DOI:10.23943/princeton/9780691159751.001.0001 |
Authors
Affiliations are at time of print publication.
Christopher F. Karpowitz, author
Brigham Young University
Tali Mendelberg, author
Princeton University
More
Less